Thursday, 11 September 2008

Those post-9/11 blues...

In the words of one of the great philosophers of our age, 'fear of a name increases fear of the thing itself'. (c. Albus Dumbledore, 1997).

An entirely legitimate response to atrocity is to look at the semantics. Today is a significant anniversary: seven years ago, members of minority terrorist sects hijacked some planes and flew them into the World Trade Centre, New York, and into the Pentagon in Washington, D.C, killing themselves and 2,975 innocent civilians in the process, and altering the course of human history forever. Because this atrocity occurred on American soil, it is implicity weighted with more significance and solemnity than any of the many, many atrocities that have occurred since. When we say '9/11' rather than 'the world trade centre attacks in 2001', we collude in affording the event and its victims disproportionate significance, significance that starts to justify the atrocities committed in its name. When we say 'Terror' rather than simply 'terrorism', we acknowledge that the word has silently expanded to encompass anything, anything at all, that the West, led by the USA, happens to be frightened of. And that's quite a lot. The struggle of different nations against terrorism -something that the British are more than resigned to, having had the IRA on our doorstep for the past hundred years - is now being treated as something entirely new, in no small part due to the semantic trickery in which the rhetoric of 'post-9/11' is enmeshed..

The plain fact is that nobody - US citizen, British citizen, Iraqi citizen, French, Japanese or Afghani - has any right to feel safe at all times. This world isn't safe, it will never be safe, not while there are buses on our streets and armed police in our capitals. We have no right to safety, none. We merely have a right to take care of ourselves and our neigbours as best we can, and waging war is generally accepted as a poor method of acheiving said objective. In most countries that aren't the USA, people understand this. But some isolated, cosseted individuals are still of the opinion that suddenly not feeling entirely safe and superior any more gives them the right to have a seven-year temper-tantrum costing millions of lives and billions of dollars.

I can already hear the trolls rumbling under my bridge about tastelessness, so I may as well pick a final nit: the use of the American date convention, '9/11/2001' (rather than 11/09/2001, as it would have been reported in the UK and many other nations) increases the tendency of the event to be historicised from a position which entirely privileges the North American reading of its fallout. And the North American reading is the slow finger-tracing of a frightened toddler. But if we're still going to run cackling with the month/date obfuscation, let's at least have some alternatives. May I suggest:

10/12: on the 12th of October, 2001, the USA and its allies invaded Afghanistan, ostensibly to cature You Know Who. Total Bin Ladens captured: none. Total innocent civilian deaths: at least 3,700 and probably closer to 5,000.

3/20: on the 20th of March, 2003, the USA launched 'Operation Iraqi Freedom' along with its allies in the UK and Australia and help and support from a 'coalition of the willing', consisting of over forty other nations. Total weapons of mass destruction discovered: a few really big rocks. Official body counts estimate that since 3/20, there have been 80,419 to 87,834 civilian deaths (that's 9/11 x 30!), although the true number and names of the innocent dead will never be known.

12/ 7 - on the 12th of July, 2006, Israel attacked Lebanon with US-supplied weapons . In 33 days of war, the Associated Press's body count gives us 1,064 civilian deaths.

Today is September the 11th, 2008. Seven years ago today, the towers went down and your world changed forever. Happy anniversary. Everybody do the post-9/11 dance.

6 comments:

  1. America will never cease to be of a general opinion that arming themselves to the teeth is the best way to live life, rule the world, and create peace. Not to say that American individuals want this.
    And, because of their self-importance (as a whole), they diminish every other suffering or tragedy in the world because they're bigger and "more important".

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes.
    I mean I wouldn't want to downplay the tragedy but it's not the only tragedy ever...the US...sanctify it. If that's the right word.
    And yes, it is NOT 9/11!!

    ReplyDelete
  3. And I love that Harry Potter quote - Dumbledore is quite right, of course.
    With reference to why words for the female genitalis are widely considered the worst words, ever...

    ReplyDelete
  4. Why is it the red-headed ladies post with such exquisite vehemence and clarity ?
    I sometimes don't find it easy to contemplate the effectiveness of disinformation on programming how I see things.
    Rick B. at Ten Percent has become a valued source so I chased his recommendation to its source - and leave my 'calling card', which in this case is a bit of a horror.
    Sorry for the shock, but I'm confident you don't shoot the messenger.
    http://www.justforeignpolicy.org/iraq/iraqdeaths.html
    More nasty surprises on my Links page : hardly a recommendation.
    If Blogger is obtuse, I'm http://my.opera.com/oldephartte/blog/

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm sure you all know that here in America the emergency number one dials is "9-1-1", which was obviously part of the terrorists' plan - to put America into permanent state of emergency.

    Thanks to George Bush, they were able to put much of the world into a permanent state of emergency.

    While Georgi is right that Americans are unlikely to stop wanting to arm themselves personally (it's a cultural thing, and many cultures share it), Americans are also strong isolationists.

    Ameicans do diminish in their minds the suffering of others - although I'm not sure that's peculiar to us - but that is also because of the aforementioned isolation. At the same time, Americans are completely comfortable accepting people from "outside" to the point that sometimes we don't even understand why there *is* an "outside".

    ReplyDelete
  6. welcome to the wow gold, cheap WoW Power Leveling, service site,wotlk gold buy cheap wow gold,wow gold,world of warcraft power leveling buy wow gold

    ReplyDelete

Comments are open on this blog, but I reserve the right to delete any abusive or off-topic threads.