Sunday, 12 September 2010

Zionism, chauvinism and rape culture

For months, feminists have been trying to untangle the complex knot of racism, imperialism and misogyny that is the Sabbar Kashur case, in which an Arab man was sentenced to 18 months imprisonment for 'rape by deception' by a Jerusalem district court after he supposedly tricked a Jewish woman into having sex with him by posing as a fellow Jew. That an Israeli court could convict on such a charge - and that an Israeli woman could file such a claim in the first place - caused international outcry, seeming to illustrate a poisonous culture of prejudice against those of Arab descent. Compared to such a clear-cut case of racism, how could the disdainful treatment of one rape claimant by the press be of any significance whatsoever? Fresh details emerged this week, however, that seemed to throw an entirely new light on the case.
Extracts from the unsealed testimony of the woman, who cannot be named for legal reasons, reveal that she initially alleged that Kushur had forced himself upon her, leaving her naked and bleeding in a doorway, but the charge was changed to one of rape by deception following a plea bargain after the woman's sexual history was revealed. The victim, it is claimed, had alleged rape on several other occasions after being subjected to a lifetime of violent sexual and physical abuse at the hands of her father. She had worked as a prostitute, had fled to a women's shelter, and was so traumatised and bewildered that the prosecution were worried about putting her on the stand to face-cross examination about her past.
This changes much about the story – but nothing about its racist ramifications. Even if the victim herself could be conclusively shown to have told the entire truth about her experiences, this would not for a second change the fact that the verdict given by the Jerusalem district court was scored with ugly cultural assertions about race, religion and fear of miscegenation.
The judge in the case declared that the sex was consensual, but that the woman never would have agreed to it had she known that Kushur wasn't Jewish. He added that the state of Israel had a duty to protect victims from "smooth-tongued criminals" who sought to defile "the sanctity of their bodies and souls". It speaks volumes about the relationship between racism, sexism and imperialism in Israel that a district court was quite prepared to convict on the basis that an Arab had defiled a Jewish woman's bodily 'sanctity' simply by putting his penis inside her, but unprepared to countenance the notion that a woman who had been abused by men throughout her life might have been telling the truth when she claimed to have been brutalised yet again.
...(read the rest at New Statesman)

20 comments:

  1. You are right that the racism of the sentence still stands - he was after all charged for sex without declaring that he was an Arab.

    As for the notion that he should have been tried in full for the original offence - I think its time for a reality check. I mean lookk, a jewish woman accuses an Arab of violent rape in Israel - even patriarchal notions of ownerhship would stimulate the authorities to push for the maximum possible sentence if their was a realistic chance.The fact is that the prosecution decided not to was because her testimony was "confused and contradictory". And this was in a situation that was already one person's word against another. In the absence of proof beyond doubt an acquittal is not a sign of "rape culture" but the only legitimate outcome.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am certain that the court would not have convicted him if he had been Jewish. Plus, in this case, I am not sure I would believe the victim's story (if I were on a jury) and that is something I don't say lightly.

    But it does raise the general question of men who lie to women they want to have sex with. It's bad, but is it criminal?

    ReplyDelete
  3. So in this woman's distorted world is consensual sex with a Muslim Arab worse than being raped by a famous Jew?

    ReplyDelete
  4. We are a leading call girls provider in Chandigarh, offers attractive escorts service, Indian or Russian call girls in Chandigarh for a memorable time.

    Chandigarh Escorts
    Jalandhar escorts
    Amritsar escorts

    ReplyDelete
  5. Find Dehradun Escorts for much enjoyment and fun contact us for top class call girls in Dehradun at a cheap cost. Book now female escort services in Dehradun. Haridwar Escorts | Mussoorie Escorts Service

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I am Priya Yadav 07490971642 age 23 a gorgeous high profile surat escorts and i am highly educated model from surat good height and attitude.
    Surat Escorts
    Escorts in Surat
    Escorts Service in Surat
    Female Escorts in Surat
    Independent Escorts in Surat
    Call Girls in Surat

    ReplyDelete
  8. Victims from rape case mày face psychological obsession pixel gun 3d mod menu

    ReplyDelete
  9. Additionally, shrewd businesspeople may consider opportunities to invest in overseas businesses without actually forming their own companies. In these situations, it still benefits the investor to team up with a knowledgeable adviser in global economics and litigation. International investments create a truly diverse portfolio that offers opportunities for growth that were unthinkable just decades ago. http://www.confiduss.com/en/jurisdictions/iran/business/company-formation/

    ReplyDelete
  10. I was diagnosed as HEPATITIS B carrier in 2013 with fibrosis of the
    liver already present. I started on antiviral medications which
    reduced the viral load initially. After a couple of years the virus
    became resistant. I started on HEPATITIS B Herbal treatment from
    ULTIMATE LIFE CLINIC (www.ultimatelifeclinic.com) in March, 2020. Their
    treatment totally reversed the virus. I did another blood test after
    the 6 months long treatment and tested negative to the virus. Amazing
    treatment! This treatment is a breakthrough for all HBV carriers.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Why is Verizon Email Not Working?

    The issue of Verizon email not workingis because of improper setup of account. It is one of the common issuesbut there are some other factors that you need to check. So, in such situations you need to update your third-party application and through which you can smoothly get rid of the issue of Verizon email not working. Some of the common reasons for such issue is when you are using outdated version of your third-party applications, disabling the SSL certificate, cache and cookies stored, or poor internet connections. These are some of the major reasons why users encounter with Verizon email not working issue.

    ReplyDelete
  12. How to Make Yahoo my Homepage on Safari?

    If you are using Apple device with the Safari web browser and want to know about how to make Yahoo my homepage on Safari then start by opening Safari web browser on Apple device. Now, click to edit and choose preferences menu. After that, choose Safari opens with and a drop-down menu will appear on the screen. Tap to homepage from the available list of options. Enter the Yahoo address that you want to set as homepage like www.yahoo.com. Lastly, add the home button in toolbar as Safari don’t have it. Once done, you need to return to Yahoo homepage whenever you want.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Yahoo! users, may find it useful to set their homepage to the Yahoo! website. To find out how to make Yahoo my homepage, click the Chrome menu button and select Settings, then check the box for "Show Home button." This will be found in the "Appearance" section of your browser. Then, click the "Change" link, and this will allow you to select the Yahoo! page that will open when you click the home button. Now select "Open this page" and enter the Yahoo! page you want to use as your home page. You can now set Chrome to open Yahoo! when it is launched for the first time by selecting the option of "Open a specific page or set of pages" under the "On startup" section.

    ReplyDelete
  14. The Spectrum Mail app for Android should be updated if you often use it to access your Spectrum email account. If not, it's possible to encounter Spectrum email problems today. If this is the case, first ensure that you have the latest Spectrum Mail app installed on your device. Also, delete your cache files and free up some space on your mobile device by removing any unnecessary files if you are connected to a wireless network at home. If the problem persists, switch to mobile data and check if you can browse other websites. Try restarting your Android device and checking if the problem is resolved. If you still experience Spectrum email problems, uninstall the app and install it again

    ReplyDelete
  15. AT&T sign-in issues can be solved by checking whether AT&T mail servers are available. If the servers are offline, all you can do is sit and wait until the system is restored. You can try the ATT sign in account every 5-10 minutes to see if the site is not working. Ensure no server issues are causing your AT&T email sign-in error by checking the Firewall settings. Firewall and Antivirus are there to prevent your computer from being hacked by programs, viruses, and unauthorized third parties. A firewall or anti-virus can also block certain programs, websites, and software to keep your device safe and secure. To determine if your firewall or anti-virus prevents AT&T email sign-in, disable it for some time and try to sign in.

    ReplyDelete

Comments are open on this blog, but I reserve the right to delete any abusive or off-topic threads.